Skip to main content

A Parrot's Love: An Early Animal Welfare Tale?

Revisiting the People's Voice, Volume 1, Number 1, 17 April 1880, after the first poem we start off with what appears to be a short fictional story regarding a parrot. (Content warning for animal death.) This story appears - so far! - to have only appeared in this newspaper, not in any other books or papers easily searchable against our friend Google.

There are not a lot of clues to go on for this story. The author wrote under the nom de plume Mrs Em. B. Dubbleyu (so likely the real initials are M.B.W., though one can never be sure). The name has not popped up in other searches either, leading to the idea this is a local author with only one story to her (or his) credit. So, what is this story?

Although the newspaper is fragmentary, we can glean a young girl, Amy, is living with her aunt and uncle, Mr. and Mrs. Fielding. On a neighborhood walk in "a pretty Ohio village," Amy and her aunt are accosted by a green parrot named Poll, who calls the girl "Ada" and seeks her out whenever possible. The aunt and Amy, having recently moved to this place, have no idea what is going on with this parrot and its fascination with Amy, and try to avoid encountering it when possible.

Some story is missing at this point, but one day the parrot Poll follows the girl home.

Every day, for three days, the parrot visited the house where Amy dwelt, trying unsuccessfully to enter, ever fondly calling “o’er and o’er again,” the name so fondly cherished.

This situation was extremely distressing to Amy, and finally the bird makes its entrance to the home, first by the door, then through an open window. Amy, distraught, tried to hide, while the aunt, who was apparently attacked in the missing fragment, was also running from the bird and screaming. Enter the uncle, Mr. Fielding, attempting to save the day:

They were near the open window, and hoping to drive the bird out of it, Mr. Fielding hit it with his hand. Instead of the parrot alighting out of the window, it struck the window sill and fell upon the carpet, apparently lifeless. In a moment it opened its eyes, eyes so full of sadness, so full of tenderness, and, as Mr. Fielding gently raised it to see where it could be hurt, it mournfully said: "Poor Poll, poor Poll! Ada, Ada!” and died.

After a bit of admonishing his wife, the husband wrapped up poor Poll and took the parrot to the owner's house. There, the backstory is fully revealed - Ada, a child, had died, and Poll mistook Amy for its beloved friend. Mr. Fielding is somewhat absolved of killing the bird by the assumption Poll died of a broken heart after the final rejection.

Parrot Silhouette
This melancholy story raises any number of questions, from the author's identity, if the incident was based on any similar real-life occurrence, and most prominently, why was this written. While we might never know the answers to some of these questions (unless further investigation of this paper uncovers more of this author's work), one idea that has been percolating in my mind is the similar time frame of this story as Black Beauty, one of the foundational animal rights stories. 

Black Beauty (1877) is narrated from the perspective of the horse, which is likely not a point of view many other writers would be able to tackle. Perhaps some of the key elements of the parrot, mainly its ability to speak and ability to recognize and bond with humans, made it an ideal animal for this tale to elicit sympathy from the readers. Perhaps there is a little sly rebuking of the aunt and Amy for being terrified of a small bird, who was only seeking affection.

Another option could also hinge on the sentimentality of Victorian-era writing, using an animal's bond with a child gone too soon to pull on the heartstrings of the readers. A parrot, able to express with words the unwavering affection seen in tales of dogs guarding the graves of their owners, springs to mind; the death of the parrot adds another layer of loss for the already grieving family of Ada. 

If you stumble across any further information, or perhaps a complete version of this story, drop me a note!

Enjoy these posts? Support me on Ko-fi.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A Fratricide in Clarke County: Part Four

If you're just joining us on this long and twisting tale, you can catch up with Part One , Part Two , and Part Three . Today's entry should be our final entry into the saga of the Little family, and it will not have any detailed medical testimony (just in case you're squeamish). To quickly recap where we left off, the first trial for Lycurgus Little was held over two weeks in October of 1873 in Berryville, with Judge Turner presiding. At the end, Lycurgus was deemed guilty of second degree murder. Lycurgus' Sentencing The sentence was proclaimed on the following Saturday, around 3 PM. Lycurgus was said to be pale but composed, "though a few tears were shed." According to the Winchester News : Judge Turner then proceeded to pronounce the sentence of the court, in conformity with the decision of the jury. When the Judge mentioned the term of imprisonment, the prisoner interrupted him by asking. “How long, Judge?" “Fourteen years,” replied the Judge; “bu...

A Fraticide in Clarke County: Part Three

If you're just joining us for the first time, you can catch up on Part One and Part Two before diving in. Since it's been about a month since our last post, let's quickly recap where we are in this story. After initially being on board with a punishment for Oscar and Lycurgus in the death of Clinton, the other Little family members, seemingly spearheaded by Columbus' press tour in Washington D.C., wanted to back off and drop the case. However, the indictment was deemed a "true bill" at the July court session, and the trial was scheduled for the October term. Columbus' press tour caused some feuds between the Richmond Enquirer and the Winchester and Clarke papers, but by the end of the summer, it seemed the press had largely come to acknowledge that the original statement and reporting in the Winchester papers was accurate. The state and the prisoners both secured all-star law teams.  As this section of the story is heavy on medical testimony from the doc...

Eyes of Brown and Blue

After our lengthy visit to Clarke County, it seems fitting to take a short break with some poetry, this time printed in the Staunton Spectator, 29 August 1894 . The poem appears to have been written quite some time before it made its way to Staunton, with the earliest sighting found to date being in 1860 in the New York Saturday Press .  Unfortunately, the author's name has been anonymized with very common initials and a plain last name, and we've been unable to track down this poem printed in another location to help us hone in on the complete name for more in-depth research. This means we've also been unable to find any other examples of this poet's work, so at the end of the day we'll have to consider this still a case of "author unknown" despite being signed. Like our earlier Valentine stories, this poem should be out of copyright in the US, so the entire poem is reprinted here. Enjoy this glimpse of the 19th century! EYES OF BROWN AND BLUE.  Out of ...